Precursors

The concept proposal to establish the CALIBRA Research Infrastructure (RI) was first submitted in February 2013 to the General Secretariat for Research and Technology, the Greek funding agency, which in 2020 was renamed to General Secretariat for Research and Innovation (GSRI). The concept proposal was submitted in response to the GSRI’s Call for Expression of Interest for the preparation of the Roadmap of National Research Infrastructures  (NRI) and was largely based on ideas developed in the period 2008-2010, when two similar but more composite proposals were prepared and submitted for funding.

The first proposal entitled “Center of Excellence for Low-energy Ion-Beam Research and Applications”, abbreviated LIBRA, was submitted to the EC in 2008 as part of a competitive FP7/REGPOT funding program. LIBRA was evaluated by experts appointed by the EC, scored excellently (14.5/15) and was ranked eighth (8) among 474 competing proposals submitted under the call REGPOT/2008-1. The success of LIBRA led to a grant of ≈1.45 million Euros. Thanks to LIBRA, state-of-the-art scientific instruments were purchased and installed at the Tandem Accelerator Laboratory (TAL) and many accelerator components were upgraded. Through the collaborations of TAL with various European laboratories, which were reinforced thanks to the networking activities of LIBRA, many experimental setups and scientific instruments were donated or long-term loaned to TAL. These included a 250 keV single-stage accelerator named “Petit Accellerateur pour l’Astrophysique”, in short PAPAP, that was donated by the Centre de Spectrometrie Nucleaire et de Spectrometrie de Masse (CSNSM), now renamed as “Centre de Sciences Nucléaires et de Sciences de la Matière”, Orsay, France.

PAPAP was transferred to TAL with LIBRA funds and installed in 2011. PAPAP is capable of delivering proton and deuteron beams with intensities up to 1 mA. By December 2012, when LIBRA was completed, TAL’s infrastructure had been enriched with state-of-the-art instruments in excess of € 2 million Euros. One of LIBRA’s most important achievements, however, was the establishment of a User Group around the upgraded accelerator laboratory and the new facilities developed during the project.

The second infrastructure proposal, which provided many ideas and useful material for CALIBRA, and later for the drafting of its concept proposal, was prepared and submitted in May 2010 to the GSRT in response to its Call of March 2010, entitled “Research and Technology Infrastructure”, which was announced in the framework of the Operational Program “Competitiveness and Entrepreneurship” (ΕΠΑΝ-ΙΙ) under the Priority Axis entitled “Creation and exploitation of innovation with the support of Research and Technology”. These funding schemes belong to the so-called National Strategic Reference Framework (NSRF, in Greek ΕΣΠΑ) of the Programming Period 2007-2013.

The title of this proposal which was drafted in Greek (see figure 2) was having the English title “Central Accelerator Laboratories for Ion-Beam Research and Applications”. The resulting acronym is also CALIBRA! The funding request was 5,75 million Euros. The major part (4.55 M€) was for upgrades of the existing Tandem accelerator, the purchase of a new 3 MV single-stage ion beam accelerator equipped with an ECR source and the purchase of a new 1 MV Tandem accelerator for Accelerator Mass Spectrometry (AMS). The remaining 1,2 M€ were for the upgrade of supporting facilities, such as the mechanics workshop and the target preparation facility, as well as for the procurement of new scientific instruments.

Unfortunately, the aforementioned Priority Axis of the NSRF 2007-2013 was not implemented as originally planned by the GSRT, most likely due to the Greek economic crisis at that time. As a result, the evaluation process of all RI proposals submitted to the GSRT, including CALIBRA, has not even started. In addition, no initiative or even discussion on national research infrastructures was on the table until January 2013, when GSRI published its Call for Expression of Interest for the preparation of the Roadmap of National Research Infrastructures . The establishment of a National Roadmap for Research Infrastructures was a long-standing obligation (ex–ante conditionality) of Greece before the use of the European Structural and Regional Funds during the that time upcoming Programming Period 2014-2020.

Cover page of the LIBRA proposal submitted to EC in 2008 (left) and of the proposal submitted to GSRT in May 2010 (right).

During the idle time from May 2010 to February 2013, the Group of the Tandem Accelerator Laboratory has elaborated additional ideas, identified and documented almost all the needs of the Greek scientific community in using ion beams and neutrons, strengthened collaborations abroad and increased further the visibility of the laboratory within the European scientific community. As a result, a sound concept for a “Cluster of Accelerator Laboratories for Ion-Beam Research and Applications” was elaborated and was transformed into a concept proposal, which was then submitted to GSRT in February 17, 2013.

The proposal focused mainly on further upgrading the 5.5 MV Tandem accelerator of “Demokritos”, setting up a radioisotope production laboratory for Positron Emission Tomography (PET), using the 17 MeV Scanditronix Cyclotron just donated by the Dutch University Medical Center Groningen (UMCG), and the purchase, installation and operation of a new 3 MV single-stage electrostatic accelerator equipped with an ECR ion source.

In its call of January 2013, GSRI adopted a bottom-up approach that allowed concept proposals to be submitted not necessarily directly by Universities or Research Centers or other Research Performing Organizations but individually by scientists. As a result, 138 concept proposals were submitted. Their distribution in scientific domains is shown in Figure 3. In the field of Physical Sciences and Engineering (PSE), where CALIBRA belong, the total number of submitted proposals was 31.

Statistics of the concept proposals submitted in February 2013 to GSRT and their distribution in scientific fields (top left). On the top right, the allocation in proposed distributed, single-sided or virtual Research Infrastructures is shown.

When all the concept proposals were collected and sorted according to their scope, type, etc., GSRT asked all RI proposers to prepare full proposals, which would provide detailed information in response to well-defined evaluation criteria. These full proposals had to be submitted now with the official approval of the research organization that would host the proposed RI, if it were one-sided. In the case of distributed RIs, the proposals had to be approved by all the “partners”, i.e., all the research organizations that intended to share a common research infrastructure. This requirement led to the grouping and merging of almost 50% of the RIs proposed through concept proposals.

CALIBRA, by its nature and due to the uniqueness in the country of the Tandem Accelerator Laboratory, which was the base infrastructure on which CALIBRA was proposed to be developed, could only continue as a single-sided RI. With the approval of the Board of Directors of “Demokritos”, the full proposal for the establishment and operation of the National Research Infrastructure CALIBRA was submitted to GSRT in July 2013. In this document, an integrated research infrastructure based on five accelerators was proposed. This is the Full-Scale CALIBRA Research Infrastructure (RI).